How to Find Common Ground While Protecting Your Meal Program

School foodservice works with a lot of people: students, parents, principals, district leaders, health departments, state agencies, and the USDA. Everyone has different needs and goals. They won't always agree. That's why knowing how to work through tough conversations is an essential skill.

Here's an example:

A principal wants to sell food during the school day. You see possible food safety and USDA rule issues, fewer students eating school lunch, and less money coming into your program. The principal sees a chance to raise money for a school activity.

Same situation. Different goals.

How do you find a solution without turning the conversation into a battle?

Start with what you both want: students to succeed.

School meals help students stay healthy, learn, and do their best. That is a goal everyone can support.

Keep the conversation focused on what is best for students, not which department gets to make the final call.

Quick Tip: If you feel yourself getting upset, take a breath. That's a sign the conversation may be turning into a power struggle. Step back, focus on the problem, and look for a solution instead of trying to prove you're right.

Stay in Your Lane, But Work Together

You run the school meals program. The principal runs the school. You each have important jobs, and sometimes those jobs overlap.

That doesn't have to be a problem. In fact, it's a chance to build a better working relationship.

Practice working together on the small things. That builds trust and makes the harder conversations easier.

Whether the issue is meal times, food deliveries, staff, parent concerns, or food sales, the goal is the same: find a solution that works for the school without putting your meal program at risk.

Here's how to make that happen.

1. Know Your Boundaries AND Have a Backup Plan

Before the meeting, know what you can change and what you cannot.

Review:

  • Your meal program budget, including your per meal cost and per meal revenue

  • USDA rules, including 7 CFR 210.11 on foods sold during the school day.

  • State and district policies.

  • Local health department rules.

  • State rules for fundraiser exceptions.

Rules can change, so check the latest information. Bring a copy of the rules that apply to the situation.

Know where you have room to work and where you need to draw the line.

2. Know the Budget Impact. Use Numbers, Not Emotions

Principals have budgets to manage, and so do you.

Help the principal understand how outside food sales could affect your program. When students buy other food instead of school meals, your program may lose sales. That means less money to pay for food, staff, and daily operations.

Show the numbers when you can. Explain what fewer meals could mean for your budget. Spell it out in loss of income per meal, per day, over the course of a school year. 

Remember, a small change at one school can become a much bigger problem if other schools start doing the same thing.

50 lunches x $4.76 = $238/day; compare that to staff hours and where you might have to cut;

Multiply this at 3 schools: $238/day x 3 schools = $714 PER DAY!! 

Over 3 months (60 serving days) = $42,840

3. Know Your BATNA (Your Backup Plan)

BATNA stands for Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement.

In simple terms, it's what you will do if you cannot reach an agreement.

Your BATNA is more than a list of rules. Think about:

  • How the plan could affect your budget.

  • Whether students will still have access to healthy meals.

  • Food safety and other risks.

  • What could happen if other schools want to do the same thing?

If the issue could have a big impact, talk with your supervisor before the meeting. Know what choices you have and who needs to be involved.

You don't need to go into a tough conversation without a plan.

4. Listen Before You Make Your Case

Even if you think you know what the problem is, start by asking questions.

  • What does the principal hope to accomplish?

  • Why is this idea important?

  • Who will benefit?

  • What would a successful outcome look like?

Listen to the answers. Repeat back what you heard to make sure you understand.

Maybe the food sale is meant to pay for a school club, support a student activity, or fill a gap in the school budget. It's probably not about making life harder for Nutrition Services, even if it feels that way!

Don't take it personally.

The principal may not know all the USDA rules, budget limits, and food safety steps you must follow. That's okay. Use the conversation to explain what they need to know, not to place blame.

Once you understand the principal's goal, explain what your program needs to protect.

Keep your message simple:

"I want to help your school reach its goal. I also need to make sure our meal program follows the rules and stays financially healthy."

You can support the school AND protect your program. Both matter.

5. Turn the Conflict Into a Problem-Solving Challenge

Now it's time to work together.

You've heard what the principal needs. You've explained the rules and limits your program must follow. The next step is to find a way forward.

Talk about the real concerns:

  • Could fewer students eat school meals?

  • Could food sales slow down the lunch line?

  • Are there food safety or liability risks?

  • Will extra staff be needed?

  • Could the plan cost your program money? How many staff positions will be cut?

Be clear about the problems you see. Use real examples and numbers when possible.

Instead of saying, "That won't work," try asking:

"How can we make this work without hurting meal participation or creating extra costs for the program?"

Then explore other ideas.

Could Nutrition Services provide food through an approved catering option? Could the fundraiser happen after school? Could you test a small pilot before making a bigger change?

Always check the rules before agreeing to a plan. Your knowledge of food, nutrition, and safe food service is valuable. Bring that knowledge to the table. You are there to help find a solution, not just say no.

6. Put It in Writing

A handshake is great, but a written plan is better.

Before the meeting ends, make sure everyone understands:

  • What you agreed to

  • Who is responsible for each step

  • What approvals are still needed

  • Who else needs to review or approve the plan

  • How you will know if the plan is working

  • If you agree to try a pilot, decide how you will measure success and when you will meet again to review the results

Thank the principal for their time and ideas. Then send a short email with the plan and next steps. If you cannot reach an agreement, use your backup plan and bring in the right district leaders.

Being Right Doesn't Mean Things Will Work Out

The best negotiation isn't about winning an argument. It's about solving the right problem together.

Stay curious. Be clear about your limits. Listen to what others need. Bring ideas to the table.

You don't have to give up what matters to your program to be a good partner.

When you find common ground, you protect your meal program, build trust, and make the next tough conversation a little easier. That's what a successful negotiation looks like.


Lora spent nearly 20 years as the Senior Director for the Orange County Public Schools (OCPS) Food and Nutrition Program in Orlando, Florida. During her tenure, she tripled the meals served to one million every five days. During the pandemic, OCPS served 46 million meals, an increase of 28% from the 2019 school year.

Lora's extensive accomplishments at OCPS inform her current work with ProTeam where she is passionate about helping to empower nutrition professionals to improve access to school meals.

Paul Mackesey